top of page

The rise of overconsumption and screen time: why we’re now craving a slower life.

8 minutes ago
15 min read

by Katie Merriman


This Black Friday weekend, it’s estimated that UK shoppers will have spent a total of £10.2 billion. Whilst this is undoubtedly the biggest shopping weekend of the year, it reflects a much wider issue: overconsumption has become an increasingly normal part of our everyday lives. This problem goes far beyond how much we spend, because constant buying leads to more demand for resources and production, resulting in more waste and increasing pressure on the environment. Yet, at the same time as we are being encouraged to buy more, there is a growing desire amongst many people to take a step back from their phones and their spending and instead embrace a slower way of living.


Vinyl sales in the US have surpassed $1 billion for the first time this century. In 2025, a total of 312 photographic negative film labs opened globally. Socially, #grandmahobbies like knitting and crocheting are seeing an immense resurgence among Gen Z and millennials. Even in-ear headphones are back, and getting just as tangled as before. 


All of these phenomena can be linked to the rise of analogue: A cultural shift towards physical objects and offline hobbies to create experiences separate from screen time and social media.


This trend has been growing throughout the 2020s, and can now be seen everywhere, fuelled in part by the Covid-19 pandemic and a growing sense of digital fatigue. After years of feeling the pressure to be perpetually online, and screen times averaging 6-8 hours every day, people are finally beginning to crave a return to more tangible experiences. The ability to focus on one thing at a time without 5 other notifications or digital escapes competing for our attention is now the attractive novelty.


Social media is full of posts with #bringbackphysicalmedia and #goinganalogue. This might, at first, seem like a great idea. Young people are more aware than ever of the potential consequences of social media, including burnout and adverse mental health effects. Now more than ever, many people are making conscious decisions to take a step back and change their habits in an effort to connect with their real life outside of the screen. 


In many ways, the rise of analogue reflects this desire. Analogue choices are more than just an aesthetic; they can also be incredibly intentional experiences as well. The effort of winding a film camera and choosing how to use the limited 36 exposures, the ritual of putting on a record and listening to an album in full, the satisfaction of making something by hand; these are activities that require us to slow down, engage with the world around us in a different way, think for ourselves, and they don’t rely on immediate gratification.


But, there is also another trend which has come to define the 2020s: overconsumption.


From fast fashion and blind boxes, which include one mystery product from a series or collection, to limited-edition items and endless product drops, we’re surrounded by an ever-growing number of things to buy. Social media plays a big role here as well, turning new trends into must-have items and turning every purchase into content or a status symbol. 


These two trends may, at first, seem to be opposites. One comes from the desire to disconnect, slow down and make intentional choices. The other is driven by hyper-fast capitalism and a desire to be a part of the latest trends. 


But, what happens when the two collide? When analogue stops being a way to consume less and becomes another way to buy more?


The rise of analogue might be a rejection of modern consumer culture, but it hasn't stopped consumer culture from finding a way in.


The appeal of going analogue


















In order to understand the appeal of going analogue, it's first important to understand what we are trying to get away from. 


There is no doubt that our lives today are dominated by screens. It can be working on laptops, socialising through phones, streaming platforms giving us a seemingly endless supply of entertainment, or filling in any gaps in our day by doomscrolling. Surveys have even shown that 63% of Britons prefer TV or phones to conversation whilst eating. 


In fact, a 2023 study found that excessive screen time can have adverse impacts on physical health, increase the risk of depression, anxiety and other mental health disorders and can impact social relationships and cognitive development. 


It's unsurprising, then, that people are now looking for ways to break out of this cycle. Analogue hobbies and choices can allow people to focus on one thing for a prolonged period of time without constant distractions or encouragement to stay online.


This trend takes many forms. 


Hobbies like knitting, crochet and other crafts allow people a chance to concentrate on a task and learn a new skill, all while creating something with their own hands.


Film photography encourages people to be more intentional with their choices. Rolls of film are often limited to 24 or 36 exposures, and with the associated costs of developing the film, each image becomes even more deliberate. Pictures taken on film often have imperfections and a graininess which makes them feel more real and authentic, especially in a world increasingly full of AI images.


Vinyl, CDs and DVDs allow us to curate our individual tastes and grow a collection of owned media rather than paying for a service like streaming. When the WIFi crashes in my house, instead of sitting in complete silence, I can put on my favourite record instead.


What connects these activities is the experiences they provide. There is no instant gratification when you spend weeks knitting a jumper, there is no algorithm choosing which album to put on next, and to truly experience a book you must read each page, not skip to the next one when your attention span fades. 


As I mentioned, analogue choices often have limitations, but that can be

appealing in itself. A film camera has limited exposures, a vinyl record only has two sides, a handmade craft has only a select number of wool or paint colours and takes as long as it takes. All of these activities have an end. Unlike social media, which has endless content and encourages us to continue engaging, these analogue activities work within preset, uneditable boundaries. 


There is also an element of nostalgia to going analogue. Even people who were too young for the original eras of vinyl and DVDs can have a desire to experience life before smartphones. This appeal is not specifically about returning to the past, instead it is about bringing specific components of these activities into the present. 


Social media itself has played an interesting role in the return to analogue. Whilst many of these hobbies and activities encourage people to step away from their screens, social media has also become a place for people to share their analogue journey. Vinyl collections, knitting or crafting tutorials and book recommendations can be found all over social media, and these trends can be crucial for encouraging others to step away from their phones. Even if the place they first see them is on their screens. This seems counterintuitive, but in a sense, going analogue doesn’t mean completely separating yourself from the digital world, it means using it for inspiration rather than allowing it to dominate your day. 


So, at its best, analogue is not about objects at all, it is about experience. It is about being deliberate with our time, engaging our brains, and thinking of the long-term rather than the immediate. 


Perhaps the reason why this trend is so popular is that it goes against what we have become used to. In a world that is encouraging us to consume more, analogue promises something different: the opportunity to slow down. 


But whilst analogue is all about slowing down, the rapid growth of the trend has created a new market in its own right. The opportunity to disconnect has also become an opportunity to buy.


The age of overconsumption



Whilst many people are trying to take a step back from the constant distractions of the digital world, another trend is moving people in the opposite direction.


Overconsumption is a trend that can be traced back to the 1800s with the industrial revolution, however, it is experiencing exponential growth now, in the 2020s. 


From the rapid turnover of fast-fashion, the frenzy surrounding toys and blind boxes, the latest must-have water bottle or something labelled ‘limited edition’, there is always something new to want or buy. Products appear, go viral and sell out, only to be replaced a week later by something else. What was desirable last month can be forgotten in the next.


The cycle of consumption seems to be never-ending, and social media only exacerbates the problem. 


Haul videos and product unboxings are now an almost constant presence on social media feeds. Platforms like TikTok and Instagram now offer people the chance to see a product and then in just a few clicks, purchase it themselves. Before you even have the chance to think about if you really need something, it is already on its way to you. 


Buying has become an experience in itself. You feel anticipation waiting for a delivery, you get excited when opening a blind box, you find satisfaction in getting a good deal or finding something which is sold out everywhere else. These experiences aren't just one-offs though; they can be repeated every time something new comes along.


Fast fashion is a clear example of this system in operation. By constantly releasing new items and keeping up with the latest trends, brands are encouraging consumers to treat clothing as something to update rather than keep. When an item of clothing is ‘old’ it typically means something that is worn-out and maybe even breaking from continued use. For fast-fashion brands, ‘old’ just means last season.


For some people, products are purely functional. Sure, you might pick a blue water bottle over a pink one, but you're still making a decision based on function more than anything else. However, products have increasingly become more than functional objects. They now show part of your personality. Even more than this, owning a viral product can now make you part of a larger collective. 


A recent example of this is Labubus - the viral soft toy keyring. Even if you didn’t purchase one yourself, you will have seen them somewhere. Either through a phone screen, plastered across social media, or physically attached to a bag on the street. These small monsters were originally created as characters for storybooks, but after partnering with the toy company Pop Mart, they took on a life of their own. Endorsements from public figures and celebrities, mixed with the marketing tactic of blind boxes, made them an instant trend and staple of 2024-25 overconsumption. Rather than just buying one of these creatures, many people turned to buying multiple boxes in the hopes of getting specific versions or the rarest designs. Like with most trends though, the novelty wore off. Whilst Labubus are still on sale and new versions continue to be released, most people have already moved on to new products. 


It is important to note that buying clothes, collecting a specific item or enjoying a product which has gone viral is not automatically a bad thing. But the pace and pressure of modern consumption is.


This is where social media becomes even more significant. When was the last time you bought something without first seeing it on social media? Platforms not only expose us to new, viral products, they also give us a sense that we’re missing out by not being a part of it ourselves. 


Overconsumption is about more than just the number of things you buy. It is about prioritising novelty over longevity, acquisition over appreciation and the next purchase over what you already have. 


So, with the rise of analogue occurring at the same time as the age of overconsumption, is it possible for these trends to stay separate, or is it inevitable that they will bleed into one another?


When analogue becomes another thing to buy


My own relationship with music has evolved a lot since I was a child. Some of my earliest memories were listening to CDs in the car with my parents, or having the radio on at home. When I got older, this became an MP3 player, which required me to buy individual songs and download them onto a device with limited storage. Eventually, I got rid of the MP3 player and moved to Spotify, where, for the right monthly subscription, you can listen to and download as much music as you want.


Despite having an endless supply of music at my fingertips, I also ended up getting a vinyl record player for Christmas in 2018. I can't remember what the specific appeal was at the time. Maybe it was the novelty of owning physical copies of my favourite albums or the aesthetic which seemed unfamiliar to me.


Either way, I was part of a wider vinyl revival.


During the 2000s, when the music industry was shifting towards CDs, digital downloads and eventually streaming, vinyl occupied a very small part of the mainstream market. Today, however, releasing vinyl has once again become a major part of any mainstream album campaign. In fact, a lot of artists will release multiple versions, each slightly different from the last.


As mentioned earlier, US vinyl sales have surpassed $1 billion for the first time since 1983. A large part of this is due to modern overconsumption and marketing tactics changing the way that fans engage with music.


Nowadays, when you buy an album, you are not just buying the music. 


Instead, consumers are faced with a range of editions featuring different artwork, coloured pressings, bonus tracks, signed sleeves or retailer-exclusive designs. Rather than collecting an artist's discography, each album can become a collection of its own.


Taylor Swift provides a good example of this. Her 2025 album, The Life of a Showgirl, has at least 11 vinyl variants, 20 CD versions and even more releases for individual singles. For some fans, this just means making a personal choice of which version of the album they want, whilst for others it creates a desire - and often the pressure - to collect every version. 



Like I said before, collecting something doesn't automatically mean overconsumption. But, in terms of returning to analogue, does having multiple versions of the same music take away from this initial reason to buy it? 


Increases in the number of vinyl variants released per album are also aided by the increase in exclusivity marketing tactics.


Particularly in the music industry, but also across other areas as well, the use of limited edition releases creates an impression that a product is only available for a short period of time or with limited quantity. This can change a purchase from being something we genuinely want, to something that we are scared to miss out on. 


Limited edition releases not only encourage you to make a quick decision of purchasing, but they also make an object seem more valuable. The appeal of vinyl, then, becomes about more than the music itself. 


This raises a wider question about the relationship between analogue and overconsumption. If we're turning to physical media because we want a more intentional relationship with the things we consume, what happens when the same pressures to buy more follow us there? Perhaps the answer lies in understanding why analogue appeals to us in the first place, and why we're so easily encouraged to want more.


Why we’re craving something real


We are currently living through one of the most intense periods of technological growth and advancement in recent history. The most notable change has been the increase in artificial intelligence. Not only is AI becoming rapidly more advanced, but we now have more access to it than ever before. 


Whether it's answering questions, planning our schedules, generating images or writing for us, tasks which previously required our own time, thought and creativity can now be completed in seconds with little input or effort.


Of course AI can be beneficial, particularly in sectors such as healthcare, but its growing presence also raises questions about what happens when we begin outsourcing everyday thinking to technology.


Just because AI can make a task easier doesn't mean it is automatically the best option. The human brain craves friction. From a young age, we are taught to problem-solve, to find inspiration in the world around us and to learn through trial and error. When we take these things away, it can have a huge impact on cognitive development.


Neuroplasticity refers to the brain's adaptive ability to reorganise or rewire its structure and functions in response to learning and experience. Whilst it is true that using your phone can involve learning and cognitive engagement, activities that require active participation give us more opportunities to learn and practice our skills.


This is why people desire analogue hobbies and activities - because they challenge the brain. If you sit and do a Sudoku, your brain remains actively engaged to try and work out the problem and solve it. If you learn how to knit, you first have to read and follow instructions, then you can gradually start improving through making mistakes and figuring out how to fix them. If you take photos on film, you have to consider composition and settings without getting automatic adjustments and feedback from a screen. For all of these activities, the process becomes part of the reward. 


Another psychological framework which may be connected to the rise of analogue is what is known as ‘self-determination theory’. It suggests that three basic psychological needs must be met in order for us to reach optimal well-being: autonomy, competence and relatedness. 


Autonomy means feeling in control of your own life and choices. 


Competence refers to building skills and feeling as though you have mastered something. 


Relatedness in this instance refers to connection with others. 


These three needs are directly associated with analogue hobbies because they are not determined by algorithms and require genuine effort to undertake. Beyond this, they also involve learning and growing different skills whilst typically being part of a community of others also doing the same activity.


In terms of physical media, the main draw to picking up a physical copy comes from a sense of ownership. Whilst you can now sit down and watch almost any film from the comfort of your own home, for either the price of a monthly subscription or for a one-off renting cost, you do not own it. If all of the streaming sites disappeared tomorrow, would you be able to sit down and watch a movie like normal, or would you have to find another way to fill the evening? 


There's also a cost element. As streaming has become the main way to enjoy films and TV at home, all of the companies want their place. There is no longer one major streamer, instead there are endless options. It's not as simple as picking the best one, because they each have different choices to offer. So rather than being tied into more and more monthly subscriptions for multiple competing sites, the economic choice is to head to a local charity shop and peruse the DVDs on offer. The shelves are always filled with the classics, Oscar winners and box sets for a fraction of the subscription costs. And once you've bought one, you never have to pay to watch it again. 


So it's unsurprising that people are turning to analogue choices when you consider the psychological reasons behind it. However, if I can understand what makes someone more likely to change their behaviour or purchase something, so can the big companies. This is where marketing can play into the hands of the multi-million dollar companies who are pushing overconsumption.


Why we keep buying


Whether it's scrolling through social media, playing a game or shopping online, we’re constantly being presented with new content and encouraged to engage with it. Crucially, all of these activities are designed to contribute to the release of dopamine, a chemical most associated with rewards and motivation within the brain. 


This process is also very present when you make a purchase. The excitement doesn’t start when we open a parcel that has just been delivered. It can start as early as when we first see an item, imagine owning it and decide we want it. The process of searching for something online and then purchasing it builds a sense of anticipation which continues to grow as we wait for a delivery.


Once you open the item, the initial excitement wears off quickly, and the anticipation disappears. Rather than being satisfied with the purchase, most people are left wanting the original feelings again when the novelty wears off. This concept is known as ‘hedonic adaptation’, and it refers to the human tendency to become accustomed to positive changes, meaning that something which initially brings us joy can become part of an everyday routine.


This can contribute to a repetitive cycle of consumption. After a while, the novelty of a purchase can wear off, and we begin to look for a new item which can recreate the same level of excitement. What was an individual purchase can quickly become multiple items or even a ‘haul’.



This is also worth considering when looking at the rise of second-hand shopping. Platforms such as Vinted and Depop, along with an increase in second-hand stores on high streets, have made it easier than ever to buy and sell pre-owned clothing. Due to lower prices, it can be easier to justify purchases, and selling clothes can become an excuse to buy more. So, whilst second-hand shopping is more sustainable than buying first-hand items, it can still feed into and be affected by the general trend of overconsumption.


So, how do we break the cycle? One approach is to shift our focus from external rewards and accumulation and instead towards intrinsic goals. Rather than looking for satisfaction through material possessions, we can put more emphasis on relationships, personal growth and experiences. This is where we can again see the appeal of analogue hobbies.


Another way is through the introduction of friction. The current system prioritises convenience and has made it possible to buy things very easily. Something as simple as inputting your credit card details instead of having them saved to your device can create enough friction in the routine to stop you purchasing something on a whim. 


It's easier to see now how the rise of analogue and overconsumption can exist in their own repetitive cycle. 


We crave time off our phones and a desire for fewer material items, and more meaningful experiences, so we turn to analogue choices. However, just as quickly we can fall victim to marketing tactics which take advantage of our new desires to learn skills, collect analogue items or find analogue inspiration online. In doing so, we find ourselves back on the side of overconsumption, and the desire to consume less can become a reason to consume more.


So, next time something catches your eye online, take a second to think whether it's something you actually want, or just something you've been persuaded to want. It can be good to make a note of the item and revisit it in a few weeks; if you’re still thinking about it then, it might be something worth investing in. And this shopping season, instead of feeling the pressure to take advantage of every deal, maybe we should consider that buying less might actually be the best deal of all. 



Further reading




 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page